1907 Northerners (G) 3-0 Ceasareans (J)
1908 Jersey Wanderers 2-1 Northerners (after extra time)
1909 Northerners v Jersey Wanderers
1910 Jersey Wanderers 0-1 Northerners
1911 No competition
1912 Jersey Wanderers 1-0 Northerners
1913 Northerners 0-1 Jersey Wanderers
1914 Jersey Wanderers 1-2 Northerners
1915-19 No competition
1920 Belgrave Wanderers 0-1 National Rovers (J)
1921 Jersey Wanderers 2-2 Northerners (joint holders – after extra time)
1922 Northerners 1-0 Jersey Wanderers
1923 Old St Paul’s (J) 2-1 Athletics (G)
1924 Northerners 4-0 Jersey Mechanics (after extra time)
1925 Jersey Mechanics 4-1 Guernsey Rangers
1926 Northerners 1-0 Jersey Mechanics
1927 First Tower United 0-1 Northerners
1928 Northerners 3-0 Jersey Wanderers
1929 First Tower United 2-1 Northerners (after extra time)
1930 Northerners 3-2 Jersey Wanderers
1931 Jersey Wanderers 4-0 Guernsey Rangers
1932 Northerners 2-5 Jersey Wanderers
1933 Jersey YMCA 2-1 Northerners
1934 Guernsey Rangers 2-0 Jersey YMCA
1935 Jersey Wanderers 0-7 Guernsey Rangers
1936 Northerners 3-1 Old St Paul’s (J)
1937 First Tower United 2-4 Northerners
1938 Guernsey Rangers 0-4 First Tower United
1939 Magpies (J) 0-1 Guernsey Rangers
1940-46 No competition
1947 Beeches Old Boys (J) 0-3 Belgrave Wanderers
1948 Northerners 2-5 Jersey Wanderers (after extra time)
1949 Old St Paul’s (J) 3-0 Guernsey Rangers
1950 Guernsey Rangers 2-1 Old St Paul’s (J) (after extra time)
1951 Old St Paul’s (J) 2-0 Guernsey Rangers (after extra time)
1952 Guernsey Rangers 2-1 Jersey Wanderers
1953 Beeches Old Boys (J) 4-3 Northerners
1954 Guernsey Rangers 1-4 Magpies (J)
1955 Magpies (J) 4-1 Guernsey Rangers
1956 Guernsey Rangers 0-1 Beeches Old Boys (J) (after extra time)
1957 Magpies (J) 3-0 Northerners
1958 Guernsey Rangers 2-3 Beeches Old Boys (J)
1959 First Tower United 2-1 Guernsey Rangers
1960 Belgrave Wanderers 2-1 Jersey Oaklands
1961 Beeches Old Boys (J) 0-2 Northerners
1962 Northerners 2-1 Jersey Wanderers
1963 Jersey Wanderers 3-4 Northerners
1964 St Martin’s 4-1 Jersey Oaklands
1965 Georgetown 1-3 St Martin’s
1966 St Martin’s 4-1 First Tower United
1967 Georgetown 0-1 St Martin’s (after extra time)
1968 St Martin’s 1-1 Jersey Wanderers (after extra time)
1968 (R) Jersey Wanderers 3-0 St Martin’s
1969 First Tower United 2-3 St Martin’s
1970 St Martin’s 3-2 First Tower United
1971 Jersey Wanderers 1-1 St Martin’s
1972 St Martin’s 0-4 First Tower United
1973 First Tower United 3-1 Vale Recreation
1974 Vale Recreation 2-0 First Tower United
1975 First Tower United 2-0 Vale Recreation
1976 Vale Recreation 2-0 First Tower United
1977 First Tower United 2-0 Vale Recreation (after extra time)
1978 Guernsey Rangers 1-2 First Tower United
1979 Jersey Oaklands 2-3 St Martin’s
1980 Guernsey Rangers 1-2 St Paul’s (J)
1981 Jersey Wanderers 1-2 Vale Recreation (after extra time)
1982 Vale Recreation 0-2 St Paul’s (J)
1983 First Tower United 4-2 Vale Recreation
1984 Vale Recreation 1-3 First Tower United
1985 Jersey Wanderers 0-3 St Martin’s
1986 Vale Recreation 2-3 Jersey Wanderers
1987 St Paul’s (J) 3-1 Vale Recreation (after extra time)
1988 Vale Recreation 4-2 St Paul’s (J)
1989 Jersey Wanderers 2-1 Vale Recreation
1990 Northerners 4-0 Jersey Wanderers
1991 Sporting Academics 3-1 Northerners
1992 Northerners 1-1 Jersey Scottish (after extra time)
1992 (R) Jersey Scottish 2-0 Northerners
1993 Jersey Scottish 5-4 Vale Recreation
1994 Sylvans 0-1 First Tower United
1995 First Tower United 1-0 Sylvans
1996 Sylvans 1-0 Jersey Scottish
1997 Jersey Scottish 0-1 Sylvans
1998 Sylvans 4-0 Jersey Scottish
1999 Jersey Scottish 3-1 Sylvans
2000 Sylvans 1-2 St Paul’s
2001 St Peter 5-0 Sylvans
2002 Sylvans 2-2 St Peter (after extra time)
2002 (R) St Peter 3-0 Sylvans 0
2003 Trinity 1-0 Vale Recreation
2004 St Martin’s 0-0 Jersey Scottish
(St Martin’s won 4-2 on penalties)
2005 Belgrave Wanderers 4-1 St Peter
2007 Jersey Scottish 3-2 Northerners
2008 Belgrave Wanderers 2-0 St Pauls
2009 St Pauls 2-1 Northerners