1998 Guernsey 4-1 Royal Navy
Royal Navy 1-2 Guernsey (Guernsey won 6-2 on agg.)
1999 Guernsey 2-2 Royal Navy (Guernsey won 3-1 on penalties)
2000 Guernsey 0-0 Royal Navy (Royal Navy won 4-3 on penalties)
2001 Guernsey 0-0 Royal Navy (Guernsey won 3-1 on penalties)
2002 Guernsey 0-0 Royal Navy (Guernsey won 4-2 on penalties)
2003 Guernsey 1-1 Royal Navy (Royal Navy won 5-4 on penalties)
2004 Guernsey 1-1 Royal Navy (Royal Navy won 7-6 on penalties)
2005 Guernsey 0-0 Royal Navy (Royal Navy won in penalties)
2006 No Competition
2007 Guernsey 0-1 Royal Navy
2008 No Competition
2009 No Competition